Changing piglet feeding schemes and management approach is key to AGP and ZnO removal, says nutritionist

By Jane Byrne contact

- Last updated on GMT

© GettyImages/dusanpetkovic
© GettyImages/dusanpetkovic

Related tags: Antibiotic, piglet, Zinc oxide, ban, China

Abandoning sub-therapeutic doses of antibiotic growth promoters (AGPs) makes no sense if replaced by therapeutic doses in medicated feed, says a Danish expert.

A change in feeding schemes and management is the solution. Increasing use of prophylactic antibiotic treatment is not, said Lars Andersen, nutritionist with Hamlet Protein, who was speaking at a seminar in China earlier this month as the industry there prepares for a ban of AGPs in livestock feed by 2020.

The Danish soy-based protein ingredient company co-hosted the seminar in Guangzhou with the US Soybean Export Council (USSEC) and enzymes and probiotics producer, Vland Biotech. That event also focused on effective alternatives to the use of zinc oxide (ZnO) in piglet feed. In July 2018, China restricted the use of ZnO to 1600 ppm in the first two weeks post-weaning.

Andersen said the principle idea behind the seminar was knowledge transfer.

Despite the risk of African Swine Fever (ASF) spread in China, slaughter pig price hikes are creating a huge incentive for the big players to invest in feed, and in professional, modern pig farms with high biosecurity, said the Hamlet Protein nutritionist.

Live hog prices have risen to as much as 25-30 yuan per kg (US$2.10 per pound) in some parts of China, more than double prices of a year ago. The Chinese pig farmers unaffected by ASF have been capitalizing on those higher prices. 

“We talked to some pig companies that have [big ambitions], such as a producer with 40,000 sows, who by 2030, plans to have 10 times that."

So those Chinese producers are looking to improve on feeding, health and livestock farming practices, and there is a clear desire on their part to understand how the feed industry in other countries has addressed the challenges of AGP removal and restrictions on ZnO use, he said.

Andersen said that farmers tend to use AGPs to prevent diarrhea, more so than to promote growth: “However, my message is that the reason they see lots of diarrhea is because they are not feeding the pigs correctly. They are giving them something the piglets can’t digest - too much protein and protein with low digestibility - and, because of that, the piglets get diarrhea. Of course, that kind of protein is cheap, and if they can use antibiotics, which are also relatively cheap, farmers can cover up production problems.”

He has direct experience of trying to formulate AGP free pig feed in a commercial setting.

“I was working in a feed mill as a product manager from 1997 to 2001, exactly the years that AGPs were being removed from Danish production. In 1998, the discussion first arose about removing AGPs from slaughter pigs and then, in 1999, we looked to do the same with piglets. So, from January 2000, six years before the rest of the EU took the same step, we stopped using AGPs altogether in Denmark. That was a valuable learning experience. Being the one [in that mill] doing all the formulation and getting all the feedback, I learnt a lot about what works and what does not work."

The formulation basics under AGP and ZnO restrictions 

Basics when formulating: Amino Acids (AAs)

  • Energy evaluation: Net energy system 
  • Protein evaluation: Standardized ileal digestibilty (SID) should always be used.
  • Decide your SID Lys level for any given size of pig. Add the other AA relative to Lys.
  • The lower CP is in the diet, the more critical it becomes to keep single AA up to requirement.

Basics when formulating: Other Nutrients 

  • Avoid too many min/max limits on ingredients; use the formulation program.
  • Use limit on total crude protein while maintaining SID AA gives optimal protein combination.
  • Limit Ca to 6 7 g/kg feed during weaning phase.
  • Know th Ca content of all ingredients including additives. Ca is often oversupplied.

Basics when formulating: Animal Proteins 

  • Milk proteins are of high value, but expensive and not necessary.
  • Spray dried porcine plasma works, but only when present. Protects but does not develop the gut.
  • Lactose for small pigs is essential. Cannot be replaced by other sugars.
  • Blood meal or red blood cells do contain protein. Due to high iron content, not recommended as it propagates Coli bacteria.
  • Fish meal has been a staple for many years, but is too expensive today. Contains a good AA profile, but also a high content of non-protein nitrogen (NPN).

Basics when formulating: Plant Proteins

  • Potato protein a good but scarce source. The solanin content is bitter and limits feed intake.
  • Wheat gluten lacks the necessary amino acids to fortify the cereals as it is a cereal protein itself.
  • Corn gluten has the same issue on top of a very poor taste, reducing feed intake.
  • Rapeseed protein is a good protein but the content of fibre that comes with it is too high.
  • Soy products need special processing. Full fat soy and normal soybean meal are not suitable for piglets.

Source: Formulation of Piglet Feed under Restrictions in Antibiotic and ZnO use. ​Presentation by ​Lars Sangill Andersen, nutritionist, Hamlet Protein at a technical seminar in Guangzhou, China co-hosted by Hamlet Protein, the US Soybean Export Council (USSEC) and Vland Biotech.

Highly digestible protein is key 

Selecting the right protein sources for piglet diets can have a huge impact when designing diets for both AGP and ZnO removal, he said.

Using net energy and standardized ileal digestibility (SID) systems as the basis for formulation, producers should choose protein sources that do not have anti-nutritional factors (ANF), and protein that is highly digestible, he said.

There is no clear route to zinc oxide removal, though. “That is not a done deal, it is still a learning process. But we have picked up a lot of information on zinc oxide and how to avoid using it, and we wanted to give people some ideas on how they should go about that.”

New strategies for ZnO replacement are being tested. But nutritionists can make small improvements to piglet diets to support gut health and animal performance, Andersen said.

The use of organic acids, primarily benzoic acid, can help.

Removing limestone (calcium carbonate) or replacing it with other calcium sources along with the use of monocalcium phosphate (MCP) instead of dicalcium phosphate (DCP) would also be beneficial as then the pH of the piglet’s stomach is lowered; a low pH is a prerequisite for efficient feed digestion and good gut health in the piglet. A high gastric pH will allow pathogens to survive and give them greater opportunity to colonise the digestive tract.

“If you apply these changes, these small adjustments to feed formulation [at weaning], you are definitely getting closer and closer to where you can remove zinc oxide without causing a lot of diarrhea."

Feed players know that if they can start animals off better, quicker, it will lead to a more sustainable and more productive life cycle, so young animal nutrition is one of the areas where industry is focusing to help deliver performance, sustainability and well-being. 

Registration is now live​ for the FeedNavigator Summit 2020: Young Animal Nutrition​ in Amsterdam, March 3-4 2020. #YAN20

Hear from experts from ForFarmers, Schothorst Feed Research, Nottingham Trent University, Scotland's Rural College, University of Guelph in Canada and many more..

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

Modern molecules to support antibiotic reduction

Modern molecules to support antibiotic reduction

Perstorp | 10-Feb-2020 | Technical / White Paper

Though solutions based on organic acids have been used for various benefits in feed and feed raw material production for decades, the developments are...

Galli Crunch, developed to be better

Galli Crunch, developed to be better

Nuscience Group | 28-Oct-2019 | Technical / White Paper

In commercial hatcheries, chicks hatch over a wide hatching window, depriving them from feed and water for up to 72 hours.

Rumi Start maximally nurtures your young potentials

Rumi Start maximally nurtures your young potentials

Nuscience Group | 09-Sep-2019 | Technical / White Paper

Maximizing efficiency is key for dairy and beef farmers to obtain better revenues. Accelerated calf rearing without losing focus on health issues is vital...

Related suppliers

Follow us


View more